Whiskeys We’ve Tried

Below are all the whiskeys we’ve tried, which episode they were featured in and what we rated them. An M or T will designate each of our individual ratings.


Bulleit Bourbon Frontier Whiskey, Ep. 2*
High West Whiskey- American Prairie Bourbon, Ep. 3*
Southern Grace Distilleries- Conviction Small Batch Straight Bourbon, Ep. 5 (M-7; T-5)
Midnight Moon American Whiskey, Ep. 6 Halloween Special (M-4; T-5)
Rabbit Hole Cavehill Bourbon, Ep. 8 (M-10; T-8)
John A.P. Conoley Bourbon Whiskey, Ep. 9 (M-7; T-7)
Jefferson’s Very Small Batch Bourbon, Ep. 10 (M-6; T-6)
Woodinville Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Private Select**, Ep. 11 (M-8; T-7.5)
Breckenridge Bourbon Whiskey, Ep. 14 (M-6; T-6)
Basil Hayden’s Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Ep. 15 (M-7; T-6)
Woodford Reserve Double Oaked, Ep. 16 (M-9; T-8.5)
Maker’s Mark 46, Ep. 20 (M-4; T-5)
Wild Turkey 101, Ep. 22 (M-4; T-3.5)
Seven Jars Distillery- Ava Gardner Select Bourbon, Ep. 29 (M-3, T-6.5)
Barton 1792 Distillery- 1792 Full Proof Single Barrel, Ep. 38 (M-2; T-4.5) §
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Ep. 41 (M-9; T-8)
Starlight Distillery- Huber’s Rickhouse Select Single Barrel Bourbon, Ep. 42 (M-2; T-5) §
Brough Brothers Distillery- Bourbon Whiskey, Ep. 45 (M-8; T-7.5; Tony-8)
Four Roses- Small Batch Bourbon, Ep. 50 (M-7; T-6; Morgan-7)
Bozeman Spirits Distillery- 1889 Montana Bourbon, Ep. 51 (M-5.5; T-5)
Jefferson’s Ocean Aged at Sea, Ep. 53 (M-8; T-8)
Willie’s Distillery Big Horn Bourbon, Ep. 55 (M-2; T-4.5)
Noble Oak- Double Oak Bourbon, Ep. 57 (M-3; T-4.5)
Henry McKenna Aged 10 Years, Ep. 60 (M-2; T-8)
Old Forester 1910, Ep. 61 (M-10; T- 8.5)
Four Roses Single Barrel, Ep. 63 (M-4; T-5)
Wild Turkey Kentucky Spirit Single Barrel #248, Ep. 66 (M-7.5; T-7.5)
Weller’s Antique 107, Ep. 70 (M-7; T-7.5)
Eagle Rare, Ep. 72 (M-10; T-9)
Knob Creek 9 yr Single Barrel Reserve, Ep. 73 (S-5; T-6)†
Blue Note Bourbon, Ep. 74 (M-7.5; T-5)
Four Roses Small Batch Select, Ep. 75 (M-10; T-8)
Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style, Ep. 78 (M-7; T-4)
Blue Run High Rye, Ep. 81 (T-6.5)‡
Old Grand-Dad 114, Ep. 82 (Shelby-6; T-7)†
Knob Creek 15, Ep. 83 (M-8; T-9)
Spirits of the Apocalypse The Walking Dead, Ep. 84 (M-6.5; T-5; Jamie-5)
Lost Republic Bourbon, Ep. 85 (M-6; T-5.5)
Booker’s “The Lumberyard Batch” (2022-02), Ep. 87 (M-8; T-7.5)
Smoke Wagon Uncut & Unfiltered, Batch 149, Ep. 90 (M-3; T-6.5)
Blue Run High Rye, Ep. 91 (M-7; Jamie- 7.5)‡
Angel’s Envy Bourbon, Ep. 95 (M-2; T-4)
Jack Daniel’s Bonded, Rebirth Episode (M-5; T-7)
Elijah Craig Single Barrel CLT Bartender Pick, Ep. 96 (M-3; T-5)§
Very Old Barton, Ep. 97 (M-0; T-4.5)
Barrel Bourbon Cask Strength, Ep. 102 (M-7; T-7.5)
Pinhook Bourbon “2021 Bourbon Heist”, E. 103 (M-10; T-5; Jamie-10)
Russel’s Reserve Single Barrel, Ep. 105 (M-8; T-6.5)
Jim Beam Double Oak, Ep. 106 (M-4.5; T-5.5)


Wolfburn Northland Scotch, Ep. 12 (M-0; T-0.5)
Glendullan The Singleton Single Malt (House Tulley), Ep. 23 (M-4; T-4.5)
The Glenlivet Single Malt Scotch Aged 15 Years, Ep. 27 (M-10, T-8)
The Famous Grouse Blended Scotch Whiskey, Ep. 30 (M-5; T-4.5)
Monkey Shoulder- Original Blended Malt Scotch, Ep. 43 (M-3, T-4.5)
Copper Dog Blended Malt Scotch, Ep. 67 (M-8.5, T-8, Bella- 7)
John Barr Reserve Blend, Ep. 89 (M-4; T-4)


FEW Rye Whiskey, Ep. 13 (M-6; T-7)
Templeton Rye Aged 4 Years, Ep. 21 (M-10; T-7.5)
Southern Star Distillery- Double Rye, Ep. 34 (M-7; T-5; Shelby-7) †
Traverse City Whiskey Single Barrel Rye, Ep. 46 (M-4; T-6.5) §
Wilderness Trail Single Barrel Select, Ep. 48, (M-5.5, T- 2.5) §
High West Distillery- Rendezvous Rye, Ep. 49 (M-5; T-4.5)
Woody Creek Distillery- Colorado Straight 100% Rye Whiskey, Ep. 54 (M-10; T-8)
Tincup Straight Rye Mountain Whiskey, Ep. 56 (M-10; T-7)
Angels Envy Finished Rye, Ep. 59 (M-3; T-7; John-2)
High West Distillery- Double Rye Barrel Select, Ep. 64 (M-6; T-6) §
Knob Creek Rye, Ep. 76 (M-3; T-4.5)
Devils River Rye, Ep. 86 (M-9; T-7)
Sazerac Rye, Ep. 94 (M-8; T-8)
New Riff Single Barrel Rye, Ep. 107 (M- 3; T-6)

Irish Whiskeys

Sexton Single Malt Irish Whiskey, Ep. 7*
Tullamore DEW Triple Distilled Irish Whiskey, Ep. 35 (M-3; T-6)
Jameson Black Barrel Irish Whiskey, Ep. 47 (M-10; T-8)
Bonann Distillery- The Whistler Double Oaked, Ep. 68 (M-6; T-6)
Tullamore DEW 12 Year, Ep. 88 (M-10; T-8)

Canadian Whiskies

Notaboo Distillery- E.T. 51 Premium Whiskey, Ep. 36 (M-8; T-5)
Crown Royal, Ep. 77 (M-5; T-5)
Revel Stoke S’morgasm, Ep. 104 (M-1; T- 0.5; Jamie-4)

Japanese Whiskies

Suntory- Toki, Ep. 1*
Ohishi- 8 Year Sherry Cask, Ep. 25 (M-8; T-6)
Matsui Shuzo Distillery- The Kurayoshi 8 Year Old Pure Malt Whisky, Ep. 37 (M-3; T-4)
Fukano- Vault Reserve #2, Ep. 40 (M-7; T-2.5)
Ohishi- Brandy Single Cask Whisky, Ep. 44 (M-8; T-2)
Tenjaku Blended Whiskey, Ep. 62 (M-4, T-5.5)
The Yamazaki 12, Ep. 79 (M-10; T-7.5)

Other Styles

Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey, Ep. 4 (M-1; T-5)
John A.P. Conoley Salted Caramel Whiskey, Ep. 19 (M-4; T-5)
Penderyn Madeira Finish Welsh Whisky, Ep. 24 (M-6; T-5)
Gouden Carolus Brewery Belgian Single Malt Whisky, Ep. 26 (M-3; T-7)
High West Whiskey- Campfire, Ep. 28 (M-5; T-7.5)
Uncle Nearest- 1884 Small Batch Tennessee Whiskey, Ep. 31 (M-7; T-7)
George Dickel- Tennessee Sour Mash Whiskey No. 12 Ep. 32 (M-5; T-4.5)
South Mountain Distillery- Sinister Corn Whiskey, Ep. 33 (M-2; T-4)
Stranahan’s Sherry Cask Single Malt Whiskey, Ep. 52 (M-8.5; T-3)
Great Wagon Road Distillery- Rúa Single Malt American Whiskey, Ep. 58 (M-5.5; T-4)‡
Ko’olau Distillery- Old Pali Road Whiskey, Ep. 65 (M-6.5; T-5)
Doodle Sasser Distilling- G.O.A.T. Whiskey, Ep. 69 (M-3; T-3)
Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Select (NC Bourbon Society Pick), Ep. 71 (M-8.5; T- 8)
Cedar Ridge American Single Malt Whiskey, Ep. 93 (M-6.5; T-4; Jamie-4)
Blackened Whiskey, Ep 98 (M-10; T-6; Jamie 6)
Breckenridge Spiced Whiskey, Ep. 99 (M-0; T-0.5)
Mellow Corn Whiskey, Ep. 101 (6; T-6.5)
Obtanium Light Whiskey Single Barrel, Ep. 108 (M-4; T-4.5)

*We didn’t rate these whiskeys, because we’re dumb.
**We may or may not have looked up the wrong whiskey for the notes.
† Friend Shelby filled in for one of one of the hosts.
§ All of these whiskies are hand picked single barrels and are unavailable for widespread retail purchase.
‡ This whiskey was reviewed separately on different episodes.

I like my whisky old and my women young.

Errol Flynn

%d bloggers like this: